Happy Digital Learning Day…and now, for some skepticism

To celebrate Digital Learning Day, SCE is going to give our sector a little tough love, and kick off a series of blog posts we’re calling “Digital Learning: A Broken Market“…

In a perfect world, kids and adults would have easy access to super-fun, super-effective digital learning media—games, apps, videos, creative suites. Technology would be an important complement to traditional schooling, empowering educators, parents, and kids to personalize and enhance learning. Children would be living in an anytime, anywhere, any-device, always-on blended learning ecosystem. All kids would have the chance to acquire the knowledge and skills they need to fulfill their potential as citizens, workers, and human beings.

We do not live in that world. In fact, it’s almost laughable how far we are from that world. But go to a boosterish conference and watch a digital learning luminary wax on about how technology is going to save the education system, and you could be forgiven for believing that we’re 12 months away from an edtech-powered learning revolution.

And you’d be wrong.

Digital learning is powerful, but it is far from perfect. Unfortunately, it’s in danger of becoming the most overhyped education fad since the small schools movement. So what to do to make sure digital learning fulfills its promise? The first step toward answering that question is to identify what the challenge actually is.

At SCE, we often view digital learning as a marketplace, and we think the root problem is that the marketplace is broken. With the help of a few hundred partners, advisors, friends, grantees, and education gadflies, we have spent the last year and a half examining some of the underlying causes of market dysfunction. We are going to spend the next several weeks blogging about these problems, and SCE will publish the collective as a free digital white paper in the spring. (Future posts will describe the work of SCE and others to repair and cultivate the market.)

As a foundation, our focus is on the public interest—in this case, as many children learning as much as possible. But we believe strongly that markets can serve the public good, and that this marketplace has the potential to serve the interests of children and society without sacrificing long-term profits. So the framework we are using (see graphic below) looks very much like a typical business innovation pipeline. It begins on the left, with ideas for new digital learning technologies, processes, or objects; and it moves toward the right, with learning moments[i] taking place with the support of digital media.

 

 

The specific path from idea to learning by children depends on the type of technology, the creator, and the business or sustainability model. For example, a publisher of mobile games must find distribution and sales channels, as well as revenue streams. A university-based enterprise may require government and foundation subsidies, and would need a platform to extend its reach. In most cases, however, successful technology development and usage appears to follow a general sequential path, with successes and failures at each step sending useful information back and forth along the pipeline.[ii]

In our view, the most challenging deficiencies at each stage of the pipeline fall into four categories:

  • Resource gaps: a lack of financial and human capital.
  • Information gaps: a lack of data, analysis, or general knowledge.
  • Infrastructure gaps: a lack of technology or common marketplace platforms to build on, or field infrastructure to support the sector.
  • Misaligned incentives: dynamics that create financial rewards, prestige, power, or accomplishment for behavior that runs counter to the public interest

So that’s how we’re framing the problems and the solutions. The remainder of this series will examine how these deficiencies play out at each stage of the pipeline—starting at the beginning, with digital learning’s research and academic community.

Until then, we welcome your thoughts, criticisms, and questions.

We’ll be collecting all the posts in the Broken Market series here, so feel free to bookmark this page and return in the coming weeks.


Footnotes:

[i] SCE’s working definition of “learning moment”: a child acquires or practices an important skill (from systems thinking to emotional resilience), gains content knowledge, or expresses his or her creative capacity to answer or ask a question or solve a problem.

[ii] We recognize our model is an oversimplification. It does not quite describe, for example, the creation of completely decentralized open-source technologies. But even highly community-dependent technology development often depends on a core group of developers, a central platform provider, or a handful of corporate contributors. We also made a conscious choice to build this graphic using a timeline/pathway format—we might have displayed the same information using a list of groups/categories/buckets, as a circle, or as an ecosystem of various players, each of which has advantages and disadvantages. 

Cultivating Imagination for a World of Constant Change

If you weren’t able to make it to Aspen Ideas this year, never fear — we have the entire session moderated by SCE chairman Susan Crown here on video: “Cultivating Imagination for a World of Constant Change,” with John Seely Brown and Douglas Thomas.

CARE Impact Interview: Susan Crown

May 2011

Susan Crown joined the CARE Board of Directors in 2006 and recently made a major gift to CARE’s maternal-health program in Sierra Leone, where she traveled last year with Dr. Gayle, policy makers and other influential leaders, as part of a Learning Tour focused on maternal health. She is a partner at Henry Crown & Company, a Chicago-based family firm that manages investments in banking, diversified manufacturing, health care, oil and gas, real estate, resort properties and telecommunications. After graduating from Yale, Ms. Crown earned her M.A. at New York University. She is a director of Illinois Tool Works and Northern Trust Corporation and has received several awards for her community work. In 2009 she served as the co-chair for CARE’s National Conference and Celebration in Washington, D.C. She kindly agreed to share her point of view.

What first motivated you to get involved with CARE?

CARE’s global reach and program approach impressed me. The organization seeks to end poverty by providing those most in need— mostly women and girls—with access to rights, markets and basic services like education and health care. It is not a parachute in-and-help-people organization; it is an organization that supports those who wish to help themselves. In my view, this is the only way to bring about sustainable change.

You are a strong advocate for maternal and child health in poor countries. Why is this particular issue so important to you?

No woman should ever die giving life. In this era of modern medicine, it is unconscionable that women and children are suffering, indeed dying, from completely preventable causes. As a society we face a number of issues that appear to be insurmountable. The provision of basic medical care is not one of them. We have the knowledge and tools to promote a healthy pregnancy and delivery. We know how to prevent and treat childhood diseases. Maternal and child health challenges are within our reach to solve.

Last year you traveled to Sierra Leone on a CARE Learning Tour. Sierra Leone has one of the highest maternal mortality rates in the world. During your trip, what did you see that makes it so challenging to improve maternal health there?

[Although] I’ve had the opportunity to visit a number of developing countries, what I witnessed in Sierra Leone made an indelible impression. The spirit of the people is extraordinary, despite nearly 3 decades of civil war. One of the greatest costs of the prolonged strife has been neglect of the country’s infrastructure. Things we take for granted, like modern medicine, education, water treatment, communication and road systems, simply do not exist in Sierra Leone. Women experiencing complications in labor are carried to distant hospitals by volunteers willing to transport them in a hammock. The busiest maternal clinics lack essential equipment like ultrasound machines. Operating rooms are antiquated, and midwives, after 2 years of rigorous training, are assigned to remote communities without housing support and are paid only $60 per month. Children with communicable diseases are housed in the same overcrowded hospital wards as children with non-contagious conditions.

At this juncture, there is unprecedented political will to modernize the health-care system in Sierra Leone. This is an opportunity that needs to be seized.

What made the biggest impression on you?

The fact that the government currently has only one obstetrician/gynecologist employed. The rest of the medical practitioners for women and children in Sierra Leone are nongovernmental organization professionals and volunteers. Millions of women and children and one doctor—it is hard to fathom.

While there, you met with President Ernest Koroma and Vice President Samuel Sam Sumana to discuss the country’s maternal-health situation. What were some of the key takeaways from that meeting?

The government in Sierra Leone has much to do: rebuild, realign, end corruption and deploy limited resources to productive activities and progress. President Koroma and Vice-President Sumana are committed, capable, clear-thinking leaders, both with backgrounds in management. They are applying sound management practices to their work and have set real performance standards in every aspect of government. The first lady of Sierra Leone is also providing great leadership. As a former nurse, she is keenly focused on improving child and maternal health. My takeaway is that this is a strong team, holding great promise.

What moved you to make a major gift to CARE’s maternal-health programming in Sierra Leone?

Few grant-making opportunities present themselves like this one, with such clear, direct, and immediate benefit. Strategically invested capital will have a dramatic, life-altering impact on the well being of women, children, families and communities in the region. As a mother yourself, what was it like talking to other mothers in Sierra Leone who endured difficult deliveries or lost babies because they didn’t have access to appropriate care? Heartbreaking. They expect so little and accept their situations as a harsh, but completely normal, reality. This trip caused me to appreciate the medical care we take for granted in the U.S.

What would you like to share about your experience with donors who have not visited CARE projects?

Talking about tough issues is one thing; seeing the faces and places is quite another. I would recommend that everyone traveling abroad take a morning or afternoon to visit a CARE program. The country directors are extraordinary. They approach their work with real knowledge on the ground, intelligence, sensitivity and respect for the potential of each person. The other aspect that can best be understood from a country visit is that CARE clients simply want what every person wants: dignity and opportunity.

In 2009 you played a key role in CARE’s national conference in Washington, D.C., where hundreds of CARE supporters called on their congressional representatives to increase funding for global maternal- and child-health programs. What were some of the best parts of that experience?

I was blown away by the fact that so many individuals traveled to Washington—at their own expense—to support CARE’s global agenda. The passion and commitment to CARE’s work was both affirming and inspiring.

How has your involvement with CARE made an impact on your life?

It has opened my eyes to many of the differences, and similarities, of people around the globe.

What would you like to do next with CARE?

My greatest hope is to be part of the team that causes CARE to no longer need to exist.

Copyright 2010 © CARE

More thoughts on education standards at the #cooneyforum

SCE Executive Director Ryan Blitstein participated in a panel on educational standards at the Cooney Leadership Forum. Here are some raw notes of things Ryan was planning to talk about before the panel ran out of time. (Questions in italics from moderator Kevin Clark.)

• What should stand for evidence in media companies’ assertions that products have educational value?

There is a hierarchy of evidence, just like in academic research or a court of law. The basic evidence is anecdote: The average kid can tell in five minutes whether a product is engaging or not; and if it’s not engaging, the educational value is zero. The average adult can tell fairly quickly whether something is terrible or, at least, possibly useful. The levels of rigor go up from there: experts or quasi-experts (like learning sciences graduate students or chemistry teachers) can spend an hour or two with a product and review it; or they can analyze the inputs—who built this, did they use evidence-based design, or is it similar to an existing product that works well? And then there are assessments and efficacy trials, which are strongest when there are no ethical conflicts, large numbers of child users, trustworthy tests, and randomization.

• Who is responsible for helping not only students, but also teachers, afterschool providers, and parents, with media literacy skill development?

We are all responsible for helping students. The digital divide is not just an infrastructure issue; it is a knowledge and skills issue. Children who don’t become digital natives at an early age are at a huge disadvantage. If you are working with children today, you need to find a way to acquire digital media literacy skills. If you manage or spend time helping adults that work with children—from principals to pediatricians— you have a responsibility to acquire these skills, and work to find a budget to help train others in them. If you’re funding these organizations, either fund this skill development or help your grantees find another entity that can.

• Might educational (teacher/caregiver/parent) guides that could accompany apps be feasible, possible, and/or useful?

This is an idea that has been around for some time, and it does have potential. We see successful analogues in parent or teacher guides that come with children’s books, in annotated versions of classic books, or even book club questions in the back of novels. You can even do this in real time—PBS Digital, for instance, has some user interfaces for parents that actually surround the child’s content on the screen. As digital natives become adults, it will be more realistic to have digital dashboards that help parents or educators track and guide kids’ use of apps.

·         How can we make evaluation of impact and a research component more feasible?

The sector needs to work to increase the demand for high-quality, research-tested products. This will incentivize companies to pay to test their products.

Until we can change the market dynamics, the organizations that can afford to pay for research need to step up. So school systems evaluate the products they use, and share the results with others. Foundations need to include more evaluation dollars in their development grants. And publishers that take corporate social responsibility seriously must incorporate more research into their product pipelines.

• What types of incentives can be offered industry to produce both entertaining and educational media?

• Are there new ways to incent “kids first content” in the apps marketplace?

  • I don’t know that there are new ways, but there are plenty of methods that have worked in other markets that no one has really pushed in the digital learning media sector yet—and they can come from the public, private, or citizen sector. It’s no secret that the marketplace responds to profit potential, and the public-interest community can provide incentives all along the innovation pipeline.
  • Large, ambitious prizes have been shown to drive pathbreaking innovation and surface new ideas.
  • Advance market commitments—basically, aggregating demand for products with too little supply—have worked in the pharmaceuticals world.
  • Foundations could use program-related investments or government could use matching grants to bring more private capital in at the commercialization stage.
  • Ratings, certifications, and trustmarks (like the Good Housekeeping seal) can shift consumer buying behavior toward higher-quality products.
  • And, of course, there is regulation, which when done wrong can stifle innovation, but at its best can protect children from the low-quality products that the free market sometimes produces.

Is there a role for government?

Yes, there are plenty of useful roles for government:

·         Regulation, of course. If policymakers can cut outdated regulations—for instance, seat-time requirements, or curriculum regulations that favor textbooks over digital media—they can make a huge impact
·         The public sector has huge amounts of money to scale up the most effective, innovative programs and practices
·         Government can also invest in research and early-stage innovation that the private sector sees as too risky, and provide common platforms to build off of (such as the Internet and broadband systems)